But you can see that the cup was chosen.

Also, I think the Lexicon is a great thing, and I use it a fair bit.

However, there is just something about talking over the subject with of Knightfans on the forums.

I know I've been away for ages, but even so, I do love the KM forum.

If I ever got the chance, I think I would have chosen the Sword or the Crown...

Now, if they'd have called the cup the challis instead, that's another matter entirely. That sounds cool, despite essentially meaning the same thing.

However, Fidjit makes an interesting point - Extreme right. Though I tend to look right due to training my observation skills on platform games as a kid

Wouldn't extreme right indicate that the Quest for the Cup was the one that people should pick, given the "Right path is right" principle? Maybe one less tough challenge in the quest?

And now some off topic discussion

There are many possible reasons why the forum is so quiet these days

"No new episodes since 1994" is probably the most likely... I mean, not every fandom can remain very active (or at least very vocal) during a 16 year gap with no new things in the primary medium of the work...

but rather than hoping it will become busy

Well, assuming those intriguing hints made earlier this year come to some sort of fruition I imagine it will become... Busier, even if not actually 'busy'.

A quest for the Cup ... NEVER occured in the series. Partly because the tile was parked to the far right! Nobody ever looks right usually!

But I probably should not have butted in anyway

Out of interest what did people prefer? Treguard telling the team what their quest was for (which took away the feeling of the team having some kind of control), asking them which quest they wanted ( a bit boring), or the choice chambers (more interesting but some may see them as a waste of adventure time)?

If somebody wants to ask something rather than look it up, it's a good way of getting a discussion going.

There's no harm in doing both, as you yourself did with your recent Harris post.

There's a severe lack of replies on these forums IMO compared to the old days, let's not discourage it when it comes up!

While my present post count does not indicate seniority, I'd like to think it demonstrates that I'm not someone who discourages discussion.

There are many possible reasons why the forum is so quiet these days, but rather than hoping it will become busy, I believe that the best we can aspire to is keeping it from falling completely silent. This is important; but also important is making sure that members are aware of the resources at their disposal, i.e. the pages of knightmare.com and the Lexicon, into which a lot of hard work has gone. Fwj's question has been answered, and he knows where more information can be found, so it's win-win.

There's a severe lack of replies on these forums IMO compared to the old days, let's not discourage it when it comes up!

Regarding the place of choice - series 4 - I remember even as a child it was blatantly obvious it didn't matter what quest the teams chose, it was always the same old quest!!

Of course the teams at the time didn't know that but as a viewer it was ruddy annoying If pickle said "Why, it's the eyeshield, master!" once more I would have rammed it down his throat! Ahem...

Between knightmare.com and the Lexicon on Interactive Knightmare, a great many answers to Knightmare-related questions can be found with only a little searching.