Series 3 dungeoneer Scott Evans and daughter with Hugo Myatt at the Leicester Square Theatre in London, 2025.

What ifs. What since? What next?

By Keith McDonald

In the second part of our epic interview with Series 3 dungeoneer Scott Evans, we consider some hypotheticals: past, present and future.


Scott's 1989 adventure as a youngster was an entertaining one, as many in Series 3 were. We've already covered the experience in some detail.

And chatting about it is very entertaining too. He remains a colossal fan of the show, to the point of having a wellway featurette in his garden.

Wait - what? I can't let that go without asking.

"My trauma. My trauma..." he jokes. Scott had a particular wish to descend a wellway during his quest. So, of course - Sod's Law - he became the only dungeoneer to get a trapdoor instead.

"I've seen two series of every dungeoneer that made it to the next level go through a wellway," he says. "That was the sign that you've made it. You've survived a portion of the challenge.

"Before every single room, you're having a little peek and looking for that wellway. Obviously not straight away, but the question kept looming larger. Will it be the next one? Not this one? It was never there!

"I actually saw the wellway prop when they were giving us the studio tour," he adds. "Obviously, it's just a blue wellway, exactly as you'd imagine. I was tempted to sprint over to it and quickly jump down it. But yes, that was a regret.

"So, I've got this feature in my garden that's a dead ringer for a wellway. I've never tried climbing down it, but it's all on point."

The blue wellway prop in storage at Anglia Studios. Provided by Scott Evans.
The wellway prop behind the scenes at Anglia

What ifs?

We're not getting hung up on regrets after that, but I love a good hypothetical - and I've got several.

Is there any part of him that would have liked to see the full virtual dungeon as his advisors did and take part that way instead?

"I mean, it would have been great to see all of it," he says. "I was a huge fan of the show, especially its hand drawn artwork. It would have been the coolest thing.

"But I was always going to be the dungeoneer. I was at Knightmare Live and I put my hand straight up to volunteer for dungeoneer. That was always going to be what I wanted to do.

I'm a professional dungeoneer, even if I'm not very good at it.

Scott Evans

"Also, you can't have your cake and eat it," he adds. "That's Knightmare. You can't see the adventure but also be in the adventure. So, I made my choice and I stand by it."

Knightmare Series 3 Team 9. A colourful bomb room in Level 1.

Scott's positivity stems from featuring in what he (and many) considers to be Knightmare's best series. But was there any challenge or character from another era he wishes he had faced?

"There's a million things I wish I'd encountered," he says.

"I'd love to have ridden the dragon. I'd love to have made it into that mine cart. I'd love to have run away from cavernwights or have met Mogdred or whoever the opponent was. There was loads of cool stuff that came afterwards..."

Needless to say, the Corridor of Blades is not for everybody. I also bring up Causeways as the show's most dangerous recurring challenge.

"Causeways," he scoffs. "What a pig's ear I would have made of one of those, ey?"

A causeway of attack and defence symbols, as seen in Series 5 of Knightmare (1991).

We discuss how the game moved away from constant single-room challenges and towards a narrative-based adventure where teams had to negotiate outcomes out of encounters. Can you earn a clue? Are you getting the right deal?

While Scott believes that youth didn't do his team any favours in 1989, he's not convinced that the narrative type of quest would have suited them better - even if a bit older.

"At the time I was on the show, I didn't have the confidence that I have now," he says.

"Our age didn't help us with our motor skills, common sense, organisation. Maybe we would have benefited from being older. A lot of stuff just didn't occur to us. But I don't think I would have waited.

"Equally, I just don't think there's any point during that eligible age bracket where I would have been able to interact confidently with some of the characters," he adds. "Some of the teams really struggled with it. Some of them had real fun with it.

"It was a good thing that I was on a series where there wasn't that much character interaction. It was a different type of interaction."

So, right quest, right time, right series? Scott prefers the word 'destiny'.

"I applied once; I got on once. I happened to be on a great series," he says. "I think I was meant to be on the year that didn't have any winners. I was meant to quest for the accursed Chalice that no one ever got their mitts on.

Maybe, just maybe, the showrunners actually knew what they were doing and picked the right teams for the right situation.

Scott Evans

Scott Evans at Knightmare Live in 2025 holding his twice-signed team photo. Photo by Jackie Vance (not for distribution beyond the interview without prior permission).
Scott with his team photo at Knightmare Live (2025)

What since?

After Knightmare ended, Scott shunned Virtually Impossible entirely. Instead, he turned to laser tag, which is where he would later make his career, in live-action entertainment experiences.

Inevitably, we discuss the end of the show and the various attempts to resurface it. He's as frustrated as anyone that the end of Knightmare didn't make a lot of sense at the time.

"It's a shame that the creative vision changed," he says. "The audience had already spoken. If something's popular, give them more of the same!

"There can be a voice in our head that says we need to progress, we need to change, we need to continue to evolve, which is one thing that Knightmare obviously did," he adds.

"And I'm not suggesting you don't take any chances - look at Series 3 to Series 4, for example.

"Make some little experiments, listen to the feedback from watchers, and keep giving them what you've been giving them. Why did it need to change?"

We concur that every attempt to mess with Knightmare's principal formula - children, blindfolded, blue screen - hasn't been entirely successful. That includes Knightmare VR, where the avatar could see the route, and the Geek Week episode, which Scott gives short thrift.

"Yeah, they just cared about looking cool," he says. "No one wanted to see someone go on the show and take the piss out of it. It's supposed to be a life and death challenge.

"You want people wrestling with decisions, feeling the weight of everything, worrying... Look at the reactions to some of the advisors on the original show when they're desperately trying to guide someone or when goblins are chasing."

The expression 'suspension of disbelief' keeps returning to mind. If you don't believe it as a player, you won’t convince a viewer, and the premise falls apart.

Knightmare Series 8 Team 5. Rebecca runs the wrong way as goblins close in.
Series 8, Team 5. Panic stations

Regarding that precious and precarious stage of naivety, we discuss the all-important next generation.

Scott has introduced his daughter to Knightmare at just the right age, and now she's a huge fan too. He shares a wonderful video of when she realises that her dad is a dungeoneer, as the family watch together.

"I've waited patiently until my daughter was just old enough," he says. "And she was actually quite scared of the first couple of episodes. Like, 'daddy, is it real?' And I said, 'well, the adventure is real, sweetheart.'

"She's now watched all the episodes with me. She's watched a fair few of them twice."

It's fulfilling to know that the next generation can be as convinced and captivated by the show as we were.

The pair attended the Knightmare Live show in London last year, alongside other children in attendance that had seen every episode.

It's all further evidence that Knightmare might be dormant but it's not yet extinct. It's still watchable. It's loved by kids out there.

"It is mind-blowing," Scott adds, "how much mileage we've gotten out of this kids' show that went off the air in 1994."

Scott Evans and daughter with Hugo Myatt at the Leicester Square Theatre in London (2025)
Scott and daughter with Hugo Myatt (2025)

What next?

So, that's the all-important question. As a father to a child in the target demographic, what does Scott think might make a new series successful today?

Having watched the earlier series back with his daughter, he says the pace would probably need to adapt.

"With modern attention spans, you know, still pictures versus animated ones being an example, I'm not sure that it would have the same appeal," he says, echoing the verdict of Knightmare artist David Rowe from last year.

"I don't think kids have the patience to let the adventure come to them. It has to be bang, bang, bang, now, now, now. So, there's that element of it."

And what of new technological frontiers? This can be a polarising subject among Knightmare's fanbase. Scott urges a mixture of opportunism with pragmatism, lest we never get anything new.

"It's incredible to think what you could do with technology now," he says. "The truth is - we do need some fresh content.

"And I do think that the solution is going to be assisted in some way by the advent of AI. You'll literally be able to draw upon all eight series, put different adventures together.

"I don't know if that's something to wish for or not, whether it's a good idea or a bad idea," he adds. "But I do genuinely think that sooner rather than later, the technology will exist."

It's also about what you want this for. For Scott, it's been less about getting it back on TV, and more the ability to continuing doing something that he and his daughter loved - watching episodes that they hadn't seen together.

In that sense, while an at-hand option to recycle and regenerate quests ad infinitum wouldn't be most people's cup of tea, it would be ideal for those purposes.

Scott Evans' AI-generated comedy skit on his end on the show.
Scott's generated comedy skit on his own demise

But what about the prospect of a fully-fledged reboot? We revisit some of the AI-generated samples that we shared last year. Does that whet the appetite or shut it down?

"They do look spectacular," he says. "And let's be clear, I walked around in the rooms that David Rowe had drawn. I was a huge fan. And I'm hugely nostalgic.

"But imagine a scenario where instead of going into purple mosaic, pixelated, passive paths with the eye shield, imagine progressing into some of those room styles featured.

"I think that if it was done cleverly, it could appeal to new audiences and old alike. There are a lot of people that were on the show who have children of their own.

"And whatever you might think of technology, compared to some of the garbage that's on TV today, this could be pretty wholesome."

This must be good for the imagination, as Scott's now thinking of opportunities a bit closer to his profession in live experiences.

"There's some really innovative stuff out there now," he explains.

"Imagine a Knightmare-themed activity where you enter a bar themed like a tavern. From there, a couple of rooms where technology changes the room around you with a lot of projection.

"I've been to places in the US that lean in that direction," he adds. "The technology to adapt activity rooms and have the experience change around you does exist. It's just not been realised in this direction.

"Something like that would be phenomenal."

Pop a lion's head above the door and a missing step at the entrance, and we're all in!

Enormous thanks to Scott for a far-ranging discussion. It was an absolute pleasure. KM

You Might Also Like...

Knightmare Live at Five

Knightmare Live, first preview show, 2013

It's five years since Knightmare Live's first ever show.

Series 3 Quest 5

Series 3, Quest 5. James is confronted by the Behemoth in Level 1.

Team 5: James, Philip, Pulok and Jamie from Ipswich.

Minecart Tunnel

The CGI minecart track used in Series 3 of Knightmare (1989).

To reach Level 3 in the third series, dungeoneers had to travel down the minecart tunnel.

See Also